When your construction project in Milwaukee requires some heavy lifting—literally—you’re likely faced with a common dilemma: Should you rent a boom lift or scissor lift? Both pieces of equipment can help you get the job done safely and efficiently, but knowing which one to choose can make all the difference for your timeline, budget, and overall project success. In this blog, we’ll help you make that decision by comparing boom lifts and scissor lifts, considering the best options for different types of jobs in 2024, and offering practical advice on renting lift equipment.

You’re probably asking yourself, “Do I need a boom lift or a scissor lift?” To answer that question, let’s first look at what each of these lifts is designed to do, and what situations they’re best for. The key is to match the lift options to the type of work you’re doing.

Boom Lift: When You Need Maximum Reach and Flexibility

A boom lift is designed for jobs that require working at extreme heights or in difficult-to-reach areas. It consists of a long arm—often called a “boom”—that can extend both vertically and horizontally. This makes boom lifts highly versatile for projects that require reaching over obstacles or accessing tight areas.

When to Rent a Boom Lift:

• High-Access Projects: If you need to reach heights up to 185 feet (that’s as tall as Milwaukee’s City Hall!), a boom lift is your go-to equipment.
• Challenging Worksites: When obstacles like fences or landscaping are in the way, a boom lift’s articulated arm can help you work around them.
• Versatility: Whether you’re repairing signage, installing HVAC units on a roof, or doing some tree trimming, boom lifts provide both vertical and horizontal reach.

Boom lifts also come in two primary types: telescopic and articulated. Telescopic lifts are perfect for straight reach needs, while articulated lifts have joints that offer extra flexibility—ideal for maneuvering around tough spots.

Scissor Lift: Stable and Reliable for Vertical Access

On the other hand, a scissor lift is better suited for jobs that need direct vertical access. It has a wide platform that moves straight up and down, making it perfect for scenarios where multiple workers need to operate at the same level. It’s the perfect rental option when stability is more important than maneuverability.

When to Rent a Scissor Lift:

• Indoor Use: Scissor lifts are popular on construction sites indoors, where ceilings need to be accessed for electrical work or painting.
• Larger Work Platforms: If you need more workspace at height, scissor lifts offer wide platforms that can accommodate several people and equipment.
• Height Limitations: If you’re working at heights between 20 and 40 feet, a scissor lift may be all you need—keeping costs and complexity lower than a boom lift.

Scissor lifts are straightforward to operate and provide a steady platform, making them great for general maintenance work and jobs with lower elevation requirements. They can be used outdoors, too, as long as the ground is level and conditions aren’t windy.

Before you decide, let’s break it down further by comparing the advantages and disadvantages of each type of lift. This way, you’ll know exactly which option is best for your specific project.

Pros of Renting a Boom Lift:

• High Reach: Allows you to reach greater heights.
• Maneuverability: Can extend over obstacles, perfect for complex worksites.
• Versatility: Works well for everything from tree trimming to building repairs.

Cons of Renting a Boom Lift:

• Higher Cost: Boom lifts generally cost more to rent due to their extended capabilities.
• Training Needed: Operating a boom lift often requires additional operator training.

Pros of Renting a Scissor Lift:

• Wide Platform: Excellent for tasks requiring extra workspace or multiple workers.
• Lower Cost: Generally more affordable than boom lifts for projects with moderate elevation needs.
• Stability: Provides a more stable platform, ideal for flat, unobstructed surfaces.

Cons of Renting a Scissor Lift:

• Limited Reach: Scissor lifts can’t extend over obstacles like boom lifts can.
• Less Flexibility: Only moves straight up and down, which can limit your access to certain areas.

When deciding whether to rent a boom lift or scissor lift for your project in Milwaukee, WI, you’ll want to consider these important factors:

• Project Height: What is the maximum height you need to reach? Boom lifts have significantly higher elevation capabilities.
• Nature of Work: Does your work require reaching over obstacles or needing a wide platform for multiple workers? This will determine which lift is the better fit.
• Work Environment: Is the worksite indoor or outdoor? Are there obstacles in the way? The type of environment plays a significant role in choosing the right lift.

2024 Trends in Lift Rentals: What to Look for

One key trend in 2024 is safety and sustainability in lift rentals. At American Erecting & Ironworks, we’re seeing a demand for more eco-friendly equipment, such as electric boom and scissor lifts. These lifts are perfect for indoor environments where reducing emissions is crucial. In Milwaukee, this trend is growing as more businesses are prioritizing sustainability in their operations. Choosing electric lifts can help companies minimize their carbon footprint while still completing their projects effectively.

Another trend worth noting is real-time monitoring of rental equipment. With advancements in technology, construction companies can now access data on lift usage, maintenance needs, and safety statistics—all at their fingertips. Renting from a company that offers tech-forward solutions could save you time and money.

You may be wondering, “How do I get started?” Renting a lift isn’t complicated, but there are some key steps to follow:

• Choose Your Equipment: Use our comparison above to determine which type of lift suits your needs.
• Book Early: Make sure you contact the rental service well in advance to ensure availability, especially during Milwaukee’s busy construction seasons.
• Understand the Rental Agreement: At American Erecting & Ironworks, we offer flexible rental terms—daily, weekly, monthly—so you can choose what works best for you.

Bullet Points to Consider When Renting:

• Project Scope: Understand the height and maneuverability requirements.
• Rental Duration: Decide if you need daily, weekly, or long-term rentals.
• Certified Operators: For boom lifts, renting with certified operators can save time and reduce risk.
• Worksite Safety: Make sure you’re aware of all safety requirements before renting any equipment.

Call to Action: Ready to Rent?

Whether you need the extended reach of a boom lift or the wide, stable platform of a scissor lift, American Erecting & Ironworks in Milwaukee, WI has you covered. Our fleet of equipment is ready to meet your project needs with flexible rental options and expert operators. Contact us today to discuss your lift requirements and get a quote. Let us help you complete your project safely and efficiently in 2024!